Top Hitting Prospects to Stash for 2025 Fantasy Baseball

Top Prospects Waiting:: Highly-touted players like Roman Anthony (BOS) and Marcelo Mayer (BOS) are starting strong in Triple-A, but face crowded MLB rosters.

Immediate Impact Potential:: Nick Kurtz (OAK) and Zac Veen (COL) have started the season exceptionally hot, potentially forcing early call-ups despite logistical hurdles.

Power vs. Patience:: Prospects like Coby Mayo (BAL) offer significant power upside but come with concerns about strikeouts or slow starts, requiring patience from fantasy managers.

Positional Needs:: Players like Kyle Teel (CWS) and Dalton Rushing (LAD) could fill specific team needs (Catcher, versatility) sooner rather than later if they continue to perform.

Why This Matters:: Getting ahead of the curve on these prospects before they are widely rostered can be a league-winning move in redraft formats, providing valuable production often at a low acquisition cost.

Roman Anthony (OF, Red Sox): Widely considered a top prospect, Anthony possesses a tantalizing blend of power and patience. Despite a recent cool spell following a two-homer game, his talent is undeniable. The primary hurdle is Boston's outfield performance (Wilyer Abreu, Jarren Duran). However, Boston's competitiveness might force their hand to bring up their best talent. Monitor his AAA performance closely.

Marcelo Mayer (SS, Red Sox): Another key Red Sox prospect, Mayer started solidly, hitting two homers early. While his walk rate is currently lower than expected, his high hard-hit rate (50%) and strong zone-contact skills suggest improvement. The main obstacle is Boston's infield, particularly a potentially struggling Trevor Story.

Nick Kurtz (1B, Athletics): Kurtz has exploded onto the AAA scene after being fast-tracked. With three homers in his first five games and elite exit velocity numbers (97.1 mph avg), his bat looks MLB-ready. The challenge is Oakland's current 1B/DH situation (Tyler Soderstrom, Brent Rooker). If Kurtz keeps hitting like this, the A's *must* find room.

Zac Veen (OF, Rockies): Veen carried strong spring momentum into the AAA season, posting a high wRC+ early on. With multiple extra-base hits and improved exit velocity, he seems poised for a call-up. The Rockies often promote young talent, and despite Nick Martini holding the RF spot currently, Veen's performance could expedite his arrival, especially if he stays healthy.

Coby Mayo (3B, Orioles): Mayo endured a rough start to 2025 after a brief MLB stint last year. A high strikeout rate (30.8%) and low BABIP (.133) are early concerns. However, his power potential is significant (slugged .562 in AAA in 2024). Baltimore doesn't have established stars blocking him, so a turnaround could see him back in the majors relatively quickly.

Dalton Rushing (C/OF, Dodgers): Rushing's versatility (playing C, OF, and now 1B in minors) signals the Dodgers' intent to find him playing time. Despite a high strikeout rate early, his exit velocity is strong (over 94 mph), suggesting bad luck. Blocking him are established stars (Will Smith, Michael Conforto, Freddie Freeman's health), but his bat could force a utility role.

Kyle Teel (C, White Sox): Teel is off to a hot start in AAA, showcasing power (2 HR early) and solid defense. Competing with Edgar Quero, Teel's defensive edge might give him the nod for a call-up to a White Sox team needing young talent. He offers valuable power potential from the catcher position.

Monitor AAA Performance:: Keep a close eye on the stats and underlying metrics (K%, BB%, Exit Velocity) for these prospects.

Assess Team Needs:: Understand the MLB roster situation for each prospect's team. Injuries or poor performance by veterans can open doors quickly.

Be Proactive:: Don't wait until the call-up is announced. Stashing a week or two early can save FAAB or waiver priority.

Balance Risk/Reward:: Prospects carry inherent risk (struggles adapting, inconsistent playing time). Weigh this against their potential impact on your fantasy team.

The Stash List Week 2: Top 10 Hitting Prospects to Stash in 2025 | Pitcher List target="_blank"

Fantasy Baseball Prospects Report: Zac Veen, Zebby Matthews pick up where they left off | CBSSports.com target="_blank"

Fantasy baseball: Waiting on Roman Anthony and other prospect news | ESPN target="_blank"