Samaje Perine vs. Tahj Brooks: Who Will Be the Bengals' RB2 in 2025?

Background

The Bengals' decision to move on from Joe Mixon has opened the door for Chase Brown to lead the backfield, but the RB2 role remains up for grabs. Samaje Perine, returning to Cincinnati after a stint with the Chiefs, brings experience in pass protection and receiving. Tahj Brooks, a sixth-round pick from Texas Tech, offers a contrasting power-running style.

Samaje Perine

Perine's primary value lies in his ability to contribute on third downs and in passing situations. His experience in blitz pickup is highly valued by the Bengals' coaching staff. While his age (30) might be a concern, he hasn't had the wear and tear of a typical veteran running back.

In fantasy football, Perine's upside is limited unless Brown gets injured, but he could be a flex option in PPR leagues due to his receiving ability. He's a solid late-round pick, especially for those who roster Brown.

Tahj Brooks

Brooks was a workhorse in college, setting records at Texas Tech. His physical running style and ability to gain yards after contact are his biggest assets. However, he needs to improve his pass-catching and blocking skills to earn consistent snaps.

Brooks' path to fantasy relevance is narrower than Perine's, but he could become a touchdown-dependent RB3 if he secures goal-line carries. Dynasty managers should monitor his progress, as he could become a valuable asset if Brown were to miss time.

Bengals Offensive Context

Joe Burrow's health is crucial to the Bengals' offensive success. A strong passing game will create favorable conditions for the running backs. Brooks could benefit from red-zone opportunities, while Perine could thrive in passing situations.

Who to Draft?

For fantasy managers rostering Brown, Perine is the safer handcuff due to his established role in the passing game. Brooks offers more upside if you're willing to take a risk. Ultimately, the choice depends on your roster needs and risk tolerance.

Who is the favorite to win the RB2 job?

Currently, Samaje Perine's experience in pass protection gives him an edge, but Tahj Brooks' potential as a power runner makes him a strong contender.

What is the fantasy football outlook for Chase Brown?

Chase Brown is the clear lead back and has the potential to be a valuable fantasy asset, especially if he can maintain his efficiency from last season.

Could Brooks eventually overtake Brown as the lead back?

It's unlikely in 2025, but if Brooks develops into a complete back, he could challenge for the lead role in the future.

Do you think Tahj Brooks will eventually take over the starting role? Let us know in the comments below!

Share this article with others who need to stay ahead of this trend!