NFL Players Facing Make-or-Break Seasons and Dynasty League Winners & Losers (2025)

Justin Fields (Jets QB): Faces pressure to prove himself as a starter after a shaky preseason.

Anthony Richardson (Colts QB): Needs to show improvement as a passer to secure his future with the Colts.

Breece Hall (Jets RB): Must regain his rookie form to earn a long-term contract with the Jets.

George Pickens (Cowboys WR): Has an opportunity to shine in a thin Cowboys receiving corps.

Several players saw their dynasty values shift significantly based on preseason performance and team changes, creating buying and selling opportunities for dynasty league managers.

Justin Fields (Jets QB):: After being traded to the Jets, Fields needs to demonstrate his ability as a reliable starter. A poor preseason has raised concerns, making this season critical for his long-term prospects.

Anthony Richardson (Colts QB):: With Daniel Jones named the Week 1 starter, Richardson's opportunities may be limited. When he gets his chance, he must improve his passing accuracy to solidify his place in the Colts' future plans.

Breece Hall (Jets RB):: Hall's production dipped last season, and with the Jets adding depth at running back, he needs to prove he can be the lead back to secure a new contract.

George Pickens (Cowboys WR):: Traded to the Cowboys, Pickens needs to focus his talent and become a reliable presence in the receiving corps.

Dalton Kincaid (Bills TE):: After a quiet first season, Kincaid needs to step up and become a key target for Josh Allen.

Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR, SEA):: With DK Metcalf traded, JSN is set to be the WR1 in Seattle.

Jerome Ford (RB, CLE):: Following Nick Chubb's departure and uncertainty around Quinshon Judkins, Ford is the clear starter in Cleveland.

Braelon Allen (RB, NYJ):: Allen's impressive preseason suggests he could be the Jets' starter in 2026.

Jacory Croskey-Merritt (RB, WAS):: With Brian Robinson traded and Austin Ekeler aging, JCM could emerge as the starter in Washington.

Emeka Egbuka (WR, TB):: Injuries to Chris Godwin and Jalen McMillan open the door for Egbuka to shine.

Evan Engram (TE, DEN):: Playing for Sean Payton and alongside Bo Nix could lead to a top-3 TE finish.

Brian Robinson (RB, SF):: Traded to San Francisco, Robinson is now a backup behind Christian McCaffrey.

RJ Harvey (RB, DEN):: The addition of J.K. Dobbins significantly lowers Harvey's value.

Joe Mixon (RB, HOU):: Uncertainty around Mixon's return and age raise concerns.

Chris Olave (WR, NO):: Concussion history and quarterback issues have diminished Olave's value.

Q: What makes this season a "make or break" for these players?

Q: Why did Brian Robinson's dynasty value decrease?

Q: Who are some dynasty league winners from the preseason?

Several NFL players are under pressure to perform this season.

Preseason developments have created buying and selling opportunities in dynasty leagues.

Keep an eye on players like Justin Fields, Anthony Richardson, and Breece Hall as they navigate crucial seasons.