Yankees Consider Catcher Trade Amidst Wells Struggles

The Yankees' catching situation has become a focal point due to Austin Wells' struggles to find consistency at the plate, despite his defensive improvements. Wells, once considered a bat-first prospect, is now facing scrutiny as his offensive production has declined. His defensive prowess has significantly improved through dedicated work and coaching, making him an elite receiver. Eric Haase is a player who mashes lefties, against whom he owns a .237/.278/.444 career line. That's been a particularly weak part of Wells' game this year, as he's hit just .128/.205/.205 against same-handed pitching thus far in 2026.

Potential trade targets include Jonah Heim and Eric Haase. Heim, an All-Star in 2023 with the Texas Rangers, brings experience and a switch-hitting ability. Haase, currently with the San Francisco Giants, has demonstrated power against left-handed pitching, addressing a specific weakness in the Yankees' current catching options. Acquiring Haase shouldn't be too expensive. The Yankees could then build a system. Rice can catch once a week in a preferred matchup. Haase could catch whenever there is a lefty on the mound and in typical day game after a night game scenarios, giving him two or three starts per week. Wells can catch the rest of the time.

The Yankees' interest in a right-handed hitting catcher reflects a need to diversify their lineup and optimize offensive production from the position. The team is aiming to create a more balanced approach by platooning catchers based on matchups, ensuring consistent offensive output.

Austin Wells' inconsistent offensive performance has prompted the Yankees to explore potential upgrades.

Jonah Heim and Eric Haase are being considered as options.

As of May 17, 2026, the Yankees are second in the American League East with a 28-18 record.

Wells has become one of the most reliable receivers in the league, with his defense ranking in the 95th percentile of fielding runs value.

Do you think the Yankees should trade for a catcher? Which player would be the best fit? Share this article with others who need to stay ahead of this trend!