Judge Orders Immediate Release of $5 Million Trump Owes E. Jean Carroll as Supreme Court Rehearing Is Sought

Background of the Case

The legal battle between E. Jean Carroll and Donald Trump spans nearly a decade. In spring 2023, a weeks-long civil trial concluded with a jury finding Trump liable for sexually assaulting Carroll in 1996 and defaming her decades later when she came forward. The jury awarded $5 million in damages, which were placed in a court-controlled account pending appeals.

Trump has since exhausted multiple avenues of appeal — first before Judge Kaplan, then the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, and most recently the Supreme Court, which declined to hear the case on June 29 without any noted dissents.

The Separate $83.3 Million Defamation Case

Beyond this $5 million judgment, Trump has separately been ordered to pay Carroll $83.3 million for additional defamation instances central to her original 2019 lawsuit. That case was decided separately from the sexual abuse case and is still undergoing its own appeals process, which has not yet reached the Supreme Court.

The Rehearing Petition

Trump's rehearing petition argues that the Supreme Court should reconsider because he plans to file an appeal in the related Carroll I defamation case that will raise "vital questions concerning Presidential immunity for official statements." His legal team contends that Carroll's legal team improperly introduced and relied on official presidential statements during trial.

However, Supreme Court rules strictly limit rehearing petitions after denial of certiorari, requiring intervening circumstances with substantial or controlling effect. The court has not yet ruled on the rehearing request, with a decision possible by July 20.

Broader Legal Context

Among the four major legal cases Trump faced between his presidencies, the Carroll cases were unique in producing meaningful accountability:

Who This Affects Most: This case resonates with survivors of sexual assault who seek legal accountability, legal observers tracking presidential immunity doctrine, and voters following the ongoing legal challenges surrounding Trump.

Why was the money released now?

Trump had exhausted his appeals after the Supreme Court declined to hear his case on June 29, 2026. His lawyers had previously agreed that funds could be released once all options were exhausted.

What is Trump's rehearing petition about?

Trump's legal team argues the Supreme Court should reconsider because a related defamation case (Carroll I) will raise presidential immunity questions that could affect this case's outcome.

How much money is involved?

The original judgment was $5 million, but after accruing interest while held in the court-controlled account, the sum is now closer to $6 million.

Is there a separate case against Trump?

Yes. Trump has also been ordered to pay Carroll $83.3 million for additional defamation claims. That case is still on appeal and has not reached the Supreme Court.

Do you think the Supreme Court will grant Trump's rehearing request, or is this the final chapter in the Carroll case? How do you see the presidential immunity arguments affecting the outcome? Share this article with others who need to stay ahead of this legal development!

Share this on: