Viral Outburst:: Kate Upton used strong language, including an F-bomb, on X (formerly Twitter) to slam MLB and the BBWAA voters after Justin Verlander lost the 2016 AL Cy Young Award.
Voting Controversy:: Verlander lost despite receiving more first-place votes (14) than the winner, Rick Porcello (8), because two voters left Verlander completely off their ballots.
Massive Reaction:: Upton's tweet garnered huge engagement (68K retweets, 3.3K comments), sparking debate about the award voting system and drawing both praise for her passion and criticism for her language.
Why this matters:: This incident highlights the power of social media in sports discourse, the subjectivity inherent in awards voting, and the intense reactions such controversies can provoke from high-profile individuals and the public.
The controversy surrounding the 2016 American League Cy Young Award stemmed from a peculiar voting outcome. Justin Verlander, then pitching for the Detroit Tigers, secured 14 first-place votes compared to Boston Red Sox pitcher Rick Porcello's 8. However, Porcello ultimately won the award based on the overall point system used by the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA).
The key issue highlighted by Kate Upton and many fans was that two BBWAA voters did not list Verlander anywhere on their top-five ballot. This omission significantly impacted the final point tally, allowing Porcello to edge out Verlander despite having fewer first-place nods. Upton's explicit tweet, reading, "Hey @MLB I thought I was the only person allowed to f**k @JustinVerlander?! What 2 writers didn't have him on their ballot?", immediately captured public attention, going viral on X (formerly Twitter).
The incident sparked widespread debate about the subjectivity and transparency of sports award voting processes. While some lauded Upton for her passionate defense, others criticized the vulgarity of her language. The event also led to a minor spat when reporter Mark Feinsand suggested Upton should 'pipe down,' drawing ire from Verlander himself. This moment remains a memorable example of how social media can amplify sports controversies and the passionate reactions they evoke from athletes' families and fans.
Q: When did Kate Upton post the controversial tweet?
This occurred in 2016 after the Cy Young Award results were announced.
Q: Who won the Cy Young Award instead of Justin Verlander in 2016?
Rick Porcello of the Boston Red Sox won the award.
Q: Why was the voting controversial?
Verlander received more first-place votes (14) than Porcello (8), but lost the award overall because two voters completely omitted Verlander from their ballots.
This event underscores how passionately invested families can be in athletes' careers and achievements.
It serves as a reminder that major sports awards, while prestigious, often involve subjective elements that can lead to debate and controversy.
Social media provides a powerful, immediate platform for expressing opinions and frustrations, capable of shaping public discourse around sports news.
What do you think about Kate Upton’s controversial tweet on her husband’s Cy Young award loss? Do you think the voting process needs more transparency? Let us know!
*Share this article with others who need to stay ahead of this trend!*
The highly anticipated series finale between the Chicago White Sox and the Atlanta Braves on Thursday evening, June 11, 2026, was postponed ...
The Seattle Mariners secured a thrilling 6-5 extra-innings victory over the Baltimore Orioles on Tuesday night, marked by Randy Arozarena's ...
The early days of June 2026 brought an engaging series between the Seattle Mariners, leading the AL West with a 34-31 record, and the Detro...
The Atlanta Braves, riding a three-game winning streak, head to Chicago to face the surprisingly potent Chicago White Sox on June 9, 2026. T...
⚠ Disclaimer: Yanuki provides article summaries and links for reference only. Yanuki does not endorse, verify, or guarantee the accuracy of third-party sources. Please review original sources and verify information independently. Managed by the Yanuki Data Engine. Full Disclaimer