Analyzing Brad Holmes' Draft History with the Detroit Lions

The Highs:

Brad Holmes' tenure has been marked by several outstanding draft selections. The 2023 draft, in particular, stands out with the selections of Jahmyr Gibbs and Jack Campbell. Despite initial criticism for drafting these players at perceived 'low-value' positions, both have become integral to the Lions' success. Gibbs has amassed over 5,000 scrimmage yards and is a favorite for Offensive Player of the Year, while Campbell earned First Team All-Pro honors in 2025.

Amon-Ra St. Brown, a fourth-round pick in 2021, is another significant success story. He has consistently produced at a high level, becoming one of the league's top slot receivers and a key component of the Lions' offense. His selection demonstrates Holmes' ability to find exceptional talent outside the first few rounds.

The Lows:

However, not all of Holmes' draft picks have panned out. Hendon Hooker, a third-round pick in 2023, failed to make an impact and was eventually released. Brodric Martin, another third-round pick from the same year, also struggled to find playing time and was considered a poor use of draft capital.

Several other picks have also faced challenges. Tyleik Williams (2025 first round), Terrion Arnold (2024 first round), Gio Manu (2024 fourth round) have not performed to the level expected of their draft positions. Their struggles highlight the inherent uncertainty in the draft process.

Steals of the Draft:

Beyond St. Brown, Holmes has found value in later rounds with picks like Alim McNeill (DT), Derrick Barnes (LB), and Malcolm Rodriguez (LB), contributing significantly to the team's defense.

Grading the 2023 Draft:

Despite some misses, the overall success of the 2023 draft, particularly the early-round picks, earns Holmes an A+ grade. The ability to identify and acquire multiple Pro Bowl-caliber players in a single draft is a testament to his scouting and evaluation skills.

What makes Amon-Ra St. Brown such a successful pick?

** - A: St. Brown's exceptional route running, reliable hands, and strong connection with the quarterback have made him one of the league's best slot receivers.

Why was the 2023 draft considered controversial at the time?

** - A: Brad Holmes was criticized for drafting players at positions that were not considered premium, such as running back and linebacker, early in the draft.

What is Brad Holmes' overall drafting philosophy?

** - A: Holmes appears to prioritize talent and fit within the team's culture, even if it means deviating from conventional draft strategies.

Brad Holmes' draft history with the Detroit Lions is a mixed bag of hits and misses. While he has found several key players who have significantly contributed to the team's success, there have also been some notable disappointments. His ability to identify talent in the later rounds, as well as his willingness to take risks, have been defining characteristics of his tenure. For readers, the key takeaway is that drafting is an inexact science, and even the best GMs will have their share of successes and failures.

Do you think Brad Holmes has done a good job drafting for the Lions? Which pick do you think was his best? Let us know in the comments below!

Share this article with others who need to stay ahead of this trend!